 |
|
|
||
|
Let the Pols Decide!
Justice Taylor rules from the bench. |
|||
|
Posted Thursday, November 30, 2000 In Friday's National Journal, Stuart Taylor Jr. dons his robes and circulates a learned draft opinion for the U.S. Supreme Court in Bush v. Gore. Taylor thinks the court should declare the whole issue a "nonjusticiable political matter" to be resolved by the Florida Legislature and, ultimately, by Congress voting on which electors to accept. Sounds like a sensible outcome to me. A decision by a frankly political Congress would have a parliamentary legitimacy a decision by covertly political judges, state or federal, would lack. (If you don't like the result, elect a different Congress next time!) But Taylor's "nonjusticiability" rationale is troubling. He says "Congress has the judicially unreviewable power to determine the meaning of both Article II [of the Constitution] and the 1887 act" (the Electoral Count Act in which Congress set out a bunch of rules for states to follow in choosing electors). Why bother passing the 1887 Act if federal courts can't determine and apply its meaning? Can't the courts at least do this until they're overruled by Congress' choice of electors? Kausfiles yields to no content provider in its hostility to judicial imperialism, but friends of democracy should want valid, democratically enacted statutes to be enforced by the courts. Refusing that job because of "nonjusticiability" is a cop-out. Here's another idea. Why not declare a) the Florida State Legislature has power to choose its own slate of electors under the explicit grant of that power in Article II of the Constitution; b) the 1887 Act is unconstitutional because it's an attempt by Congress to regulate and limit this Article II power of the state legislature, and you can't change the Constitution with a statute; and c) if Congress doesn't like what the Florida Legislature has done, it can ignore that legislature's action and validate competing electors, using its power to "count" electors under the 12th Amendment? The result would be a constitutional mechanism that leaves the decision in the hands of elected pols, where Taylor persuasively argues it belongs, but without creating a weird mutant class of election statutes that can't be enforced by the courts. ... [Who got better grades in law school, you or Taylor?--Ed. I respectfully refuse to answer that question.] P.S.: I'm not saying the Florida Legislature should intervene. That would be ugly. It's obviously better to have an election with a result. I'm just saying they have the power to intervene under Article II's pretty-darn-explicit language. ("Each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors. ...") New E-mail service: Sign up, using the ListBot gizmo below, and you will be notified by e-mail whenever there's a new item on kausfiles.com. [Note: this service is free. You'll be asked a couple of demographic questions; if you find them annoying just leave them unanswered.] | ||||
|
Recently archived: Gore vs. the Mysterious Forces The trouble with the Democrats' Shrumarama in L.A.. Cheney: Cheerleader for OPEC Let those Yankees in key Midwest battleground states freeze in the dark! Bush and Cheney: The Secret Transcripts Crock of Goldstein WaPo welfare reporter falls for Brookings spin, and worse. The Real Hillary Scandal Mr. and Mrs. Clinton forgot to get their stories straight. The Gift of Nader Gore could use a rival on his left. Rehnquist's Scandalous Shmatte Did he deduct that $30,000 robe? What's He Hiding? Notes toward a unified Bush theory. Special Re-Flogging Edition More on WaPo's hypocritical critic. CBS's Defective Defector 60 Minutes adopts Internet news standards. Looking for Mr. Good Death Mickey's Assignment Desk #8. Another Greenhouse Effect Resurgence of "labor resurgence" stories puzzles experts. Crosswired Politics Why the parties are trading places on some issues. The Toobin Crisis, Day 141 Ann Godoff vs. Charles Peters. The Purnick Platform The new NYT lets it all hang out. Run, Peggy, Run! The best anti-Hillary candidate. Kuttner's Poor Statistics Have child poverty rates 'scarcely moved'? Drew's Cluelessness Please don't let her anywhere near the First Amendment. Why Gore Won't Pick Richardson An impolite thought .... How Convenient! Now McCain tells us. Now She's Done It Maybe that nice centrist Mrs. Clinton really is against welfare reform. Pardon Our Reporting Clinton left the door wide open! Elian: An Overlooked Angle? Castro did Clinton a big favor last year. Boomers Against Death The shift against the death penalty isn't necessarily a shift to the left. The Perfect Campaign All e-mail, all the time! No Justice, No Paez The LAT and 'judicial activism.' Kausfiles Battles for the Vital Center! Why Bush has plenty of time to reposition himself. Clean Sheets The case for selling the Lincoln Bedroom. Don't Push It, Hillary Plus: kausfiles moves its cheese! Faster Politics Why 'momentum' ain't what it used to be. Jeffrey Toobin, Chicken! Fifth of a series. Hillary's Shocking Truth Plus: the Nissan Cojones Watch. Hit Poems A kausfiles contest. Gore's Press Problem Plus: How he blew his chance for a New Hampshire knockout. Bush Knows What "Regatta" Means Bradley's SATS; the media's moodswing; the neolibs' nightmare. Jeffrey Toobin, Hypocrite, Part III! How dare Isikoff write a book, says Toobin in his book. Not Gotcha Why Gore's gay flip was a genuine gaffe. Pay Up, Shrum! Litmus test flip-flop smoking gun. Jeffrey Toobin, Hypocrite 'Tawdry voyeurism,' anyone? Cuomo Family Values Did Mario raise his son to be Hillary's Boy? DeParle Gets Half the Story The NYT doesn't tell us what we need to know about Milwaukee's poor. Bill Clinton Wants You on Welfare! Is this the dole administration after all? The Pornographer Who Didn't Bark Why wouldn't Flynt bust Newt? Yes, There Are Easy Answers! The NYT and WaPo find a quick fix for affirmative action. Who Stole Nissan's Cojones? Jerry Hirshberg'a got a lot of ... chutzpah! Doesn't Anyone Want to Be Famous? The political opportunity of a lifetime. The Ending of the Black Underclass, Part XVIII African-American welfare receipt falls to new low. Just Buzz Me! Synergy City! Harvey Weinstein plans a TV show based on Talk. Is Daniel Patrick Moynihan the Devil? A review of the evidence to date. Harvey Scores Again! An exciting new Talk contest. Is It Over? Clinton's Pathetic Second Term Revealing the one Big Thing he still might accomplish. Maybe Bush Didn't Snort Coke -- Maybe He Dropped Acid! One solution to the Bush drug mystery. George Bush, Drug Pioneer? Bush's pharmacological time-line seems a little ... out of the mainstream. Will Tina Fire Lucinda? Talk and truth. Copyright 2000 Mickey Kaus. 
|
|||
